Apple iPhone: the mania is started...

The rumours about the new Apple iPhone are finished today: in USA this new Apple device goes on sale today, but here in Europe we'll have to wait at least to the end of the year.

A new device mania is started and Apple has a great touch: it has the ability to transform every device it's ready to launch in a so desiderable and fashionable toy...

But if you forget the fashion and observ the reality, are you sure that the iPhone is so revolutionary?

Msmobiles has published a nice "real world" comparison between the iPhone and the Windows Mobile devices available. This is the summary:

  • multi-touch technology (display detects more than one point of contact)
    • iPhone : yes
    • Windows Mobile : no
  • touch screen with "drag, throw, lift the finger and observe scrolling" technology
    • iPhone : yes
    • Windows Mobile : yes (now: TouchFLO technology available only in HTC Touch phone, soon more phones available with it)
  • built-in GPS
    • iPhone : no
    • Windows Mobile : yes (in some models)
  • can run 3rd party stand-alone applications
    • iPhone : no (so no SlingPlayer, no eBook readers, no other 3rd party software!)
    • Windows Mobile : yes (both native code and managed code [.NET, but some models also Java])
  • can run AJAX web applications inside of the Internet browser
    • iPhone : yes (limited to abilities of Safari browser)
    • Windows Mobile : yes (limited to abilities of various browsers, for example: NetFront or Opera Mobile)
  • voice over IP
    • iPhone : no
    • Windows Mobile : yes (including original Skype Mobile and several SIP clients)
  • support for 3G cellular networks = wireless broadband speeds
    • iPhone : no, only EDGE (2.5G technology, slower)
    • Windows Mobile : yes, including HSDPA 3.6 MB/s, UMTS, CDMA EVDO
  • display resolution
    • iPhone : 480x320 pixels
    • Windows Mobile : depending on model : 800x480, 640x480, 320x320, 320x240, 240x240, 176x220
  • camera
    • iPhone : 2 megapixel without autofocus
    • Windows Mobile : depending on model : 2-3 megapixel, some models with autofocus and macro mode
  • internal storage
    • iPhone : 4GB or 8GB
    • Windows Mobile : memory card slot with support 2GB or 4GB in case of the standard cards (some models support though SDHC and thus 8GB and more - no limits)
  • stereo audio over Bluetooth
    • iPhone : no
    • Windows Mobile : yes
  • physical keyboard
    • iPhone : no
    • Windows Mobile : yes (some models)
  • virtual keyboard
    • iPhone : yes
    • Windows Mobile : yes (in some models also with T9 predictive text input)
  • scroll wheel
    • iPhone : no
    • Windows Mobile : yes (some models)
  • visual voice mail
    • iPhone : yes
    • Windows Mobile : yes (available as 3rd party download)
  • Wi-Fi
    • iPhone : yes
    • Windows Mobile : yes (some models)
  • viewing and editing Microsoft Office documents
    • iPhone : no
    • Windows Mobile : yes
  • Microsoft Direct Push email
    • iPhone : no (only IMAP connection to Microsoft Exchange)
    • Windows Mobile : yes
  • instant messaging (I.M.)
    • iPhone : no
    • Windows Mobile : yes (Live Messenger with file transfer ability built-in + several 3rd party I.M. programs available)
  • ability to connect external hardware
    • iPhone : no
    • Windows Mobile : yes (through SD/SDIO interface + through USB host feature in some models)

Conclusion: as you can see above in several areas Windows Mobile phones are superior to Apple iPhone.

My two cents? Apple iPhone is surely a fascinating object and I'm really curious to read the first reviews (expecially about the usability and the battery life) but Windows Mobile devices has actually a great "plus" (for a developer): you can have the ability to build your own application with the .NET platform!!  

Unvaluable...

Print | posted on Saturday, June 30, 2007 2:24 PM

Comments on this post

# re: Apple iPhone: the mania is started...

Requesting Gravatar...
iPhone was a long time coming - it was predicted in 1979...
Left by Paul Levinson on Jun 30, 2007 2:53 PM

# re: Apple iPhone: the mania is started...

Requesting Gravatar...
Paul, your book seems really interesting. Thanks for sharing.
Left by Stefano Demiliani on Jun 30, 2007 2:55 PM

Your comment:

 (will show your gravatar)
 
Please add 2 and 2 and type the answer here: