Should I install XP SP2?

With the XP SP2 availability on Windows Update, I think that many people are still unsure of whether they should download and install SP2 or not. Will I gain something or will I loose something?

I think that what you could gain with XP SP2 are 2 things:

  • more security: the new Windows Firewall is not so good as I could expect from this product (there are too many better firewall out on the market and the new Firewall lacks in many feature) but is better than the native XP Firewall (if you consider it a real "firewall" ). The Popup Blocker feature for IE is what we're waiting from years and it's a must to have (maybe a browser changement is the ideal choice ), the same for the Download Manager. Obviously, keep this is your mind: installing XP SP2 is not equal to "My system is secure!" but "My system has something more about security"
  • better WiFi support: with XP SP2 you could have a native Bluetooth support (I was waiting for it) and improved Wireless features.

Where you can loose?

I think that if you're not a "lamer" and you know how to administer your system (expecially how to configure your new firewall) you loose nothing. Obviously, if you don't know how to set your firewall options, you can have lots of problems with some applications.

According to what I write above, here you can find an interesting test about Performance comparison between XP SP1 and XP SP2.

Read it... as you can expect, there's not a loose on performance between SP1 and SP2. So, what's your decision?

Print | posted on Thursday, September 09, 2004 11:59 AM

Comments on this post

# re: Should I install XP SP2?

Requesting Gravatar...
At the moment I don't see the advantage. I have seen numerous reports about issues with installation (including a largish percentage who have to reinstall their machine) http://news.bbc.co.uk/nolpda/ukfs_news/hi/newsid_3557000/3557952.stm

I plan to wait until I have to wipe and reinstall anyway, the risk is just too great right now.
Left by Scott Galloway on Sep 09, 2004 8:20 AM

# re: Should I install XP SP2?

Requesting Gravatar...
I've installed every alpha and beta of it since last year... so for me it's not a problem at all!!!
Left by Lorenzo Barbieri on Sep 09, 2004 10:24 AM

# re: Should I install XP SP2?

Requesting Gravatar...
I have heard a lot of people having problems so I installed it just to see exactly what the problems were. I had absolutely NO problems. Make sure you understand how to configure a firewall (or turn it off if you have a router) and how to configure the pop-up blocker. I know people love to hate Microsoft, but there has been nothing but good things happening with my installation of XP SP2. Also, don't forget to run windows update as there are even more updates available.
Left by John H on Sep 09, 2004 11:26 AM

Your comment:

 (will show your gravatar)
 
Please add 5 and 3 and type the answer here: